Skip to main content

Understanding the difficulties faced by people with sight problems

Posted by: , Posted on: - Categories: Accessibility, People, Service design, User research

Image of two women wearing goggles that simulate visual impairments

As a user researcher, I'm always looking for ways to help teams develop an understanding of the people they're building products and services for.

Over 30 years of working in sectors as diverse as telecommunications, pharmaceuticals and education, the quest for empathy has taken many forms. I have:

  • taken developers to cold, wet fields where they swapped keyboards for hard hats and observed telecommunication masts being installed
  • set up video links so that test teams could watch scientists attempt to interpret high-tech representations of complex chemical reactions
  • seen designers return to classrooms to learn from the same materials and sit in the same seats as students taking their end of year assessments

However strange the techniques, the benefits are clear. The team questions their design and how it is implemented, checking at every step that it will contribute positively to achieving users’ goals.

This delivers better products faster, more efficiently and reduces the cost associated with re-working a product that has poor usability; ultimately leading to a satisfying user experience.

Developing empathy

When the objects, terminology and sequences in the user’s world are unfamiliar to you, developing empathy is challenge enough. However, when your audience experiences every aspect of the world differently, the challenge takes on another dimension.

Accessibility testing is a mandatory step in DVSA’s development processes. The GOV.UK Design System that we follow includes styles and patterns that can help to make sure a service is usable by physically disabled users as well as those with mental impairments.

As well as following the guidance in the GOV.UK Service Manual on making your service accessible, we wanted to develop empathy with users with a disability.

Simulating visual impairments

Image of a set of 10 goggles that simulate visual impairments in a case
The Visual Impairment North East (Vine) Simulation Package

DVSA recently bought a set of goggles that simulate a range of visual impairments. They include cataracts, tunnel vision, and loss of parts of the visual field associated with diabetes, stroke and macular degeneration.

By donning a pair of goggles, it was possible to see the world through the eyes of another person.

To gain deeper insight into what it would be like to live with the different types of visual impairment, we developed a series of tasks that would be typical for users of our digital service for vehicle operators. This service lets lorry, bus and coach operators apply for and manage their operator licence.

The task that we chose is our highest volume transaction: adding and removing vehicles from a licence. This involves finding and changing vehicle details, such as the registration number and vehicle weight. Around 80,000 operators do around 340,000 of these vehicle changes a year.

So, people in our product teams spent 25 minutes wearing the goggles and using the service to add and remove vehicles from a licence.

Understanding the impact

Image of one man wearing visual impairment simulation googles using a laptop, and another man wearing visual impairment simulation goggles looking at a sheet of paper

Taking part in our accessibility sessions has provided insights on a number of levels.

Once the participants had become familiar with the limitations being placed on their vision, they turned their attention to understanding the impact on someone trying to complete their day-to-day work.

They thought beyond the immediate experience to identify the important elements of the interaction which were causing difficulties. Here's what they said:

This really makes you think. Everything is so much slower, and it is really difficult to check what you have done.

I could achieve the task, but it took all of my concentration. Any complication like an extra step or additional information was just too much.

Some also related the experiences back to the tools and techniques we use when designing a service.

I used to be irritated by the way our design system made us break tasks down into single steps, but I completely get the importance of it now.

Living with visual impairments

After commenting on how difficult they found it to complete tasks themselves, the team started to reflect on what life must be like for people who have some kind of visual impairment. It was common to hear comments such as:

I always wondered why he tipped his head like that.

Now I know why she sometimes bumps into things.

That must be why she always has her the text on her screen set so large.

From developers to senior managers

Initially, we saw this as a small-scale activity for our immediate development team. But the experience has proved so engaging that 46 people from our Leeds and Nottingham offices have tried the goggles so far.

This includes developers, testers, analysts, caseworkers, team leaders and senior managers.

Interest continues to grow. In November, I'll be taking the goggles to the Office of the Traffic Commissioners' annual conference where even more people will be able to take part in the experience.

It's a significant investment by DVSA in understanding accessibility issues.

This is for everyone

From what we've done so far, we've identified a number of changes that we can make to our design that will improve the user experience for all. These include:

  • increasing the contrast between text and its background
  • ensuring the spacing between controls is sufficient that the controls can be discriminated
  • increasing readability of lists

We're currently creating pieces of work which will fix these issues across the whole service.

We'll then engage with users with other challenges due to a range of physical and mental conditions.

We're also working with Enabled, our staff network group representing colleagues who have impairments or may need workplace adjustments. This will give us more insights and help us identify new ways to improve our service.

Having been through this experience, we feel that we have a much-improved capability to make a product that really is for everyone.

Keep up to date with our work by signing up for email alerts or following DVSA digital on Twitter.

Sharing and comments

Share this page